Thursday, April 28, 2011

Micro Finance Credit Up

Despite persistent complaints by the private sector of a squeeze in credit, there has in recent times been an explosion of finance in the micro finance sector.

The Chief Executive Officer of Dalex Finance & Leasing Company Limited, Mr. Kenneth Kwamina Thompson, in an interview with Business and Financial Times observed that the expansion of credit to the sector is a good thing.

As at 31st March 2011, Survey of Apex Bodies indicate that at least 200 microfinance companies operating under the Money Lenders Ordinance had registered with the Association of Microfinance Companies. However, estimates of over 1,000 such companies exist throughout Ghana. Some individual Susu Collectors have graduated into such companies. In the informal financial sector, at least 2,000 Susu collectors have registered with the Ghana Cooperative Susu Collectors Association, but estimates of over 5,000 exist nationwide. “In the light of increasing complaints by Ghanaian entrepreneurs that lack of access to credit hinders growth, the proliferation of financial institutions that provide entrepreneurs easy access to credit is a positive development; however, regulation needs to be formalised to minimise the risks to both lenders and borrowers.”

Most organisations operating in the sector are typically owned by people who themselves are not involved in the day to day management, as they have other commitments. The micro-finance institutions, usually located in marketplaces such as Kasoa and Agblogbloshie, advance loans with interest rates ranging between 10 – 30 percent per month. Money is lent to individuals, but mainly to groups with no security required except for reliance on the collective responsibility of the group to ensure repayment.

The main issues of concern to the micro finance institutions include how to keep their operational costs down as monitoring costs are high whilst staff wages, which are typically low, could affect risk assessment. “The expansion of credit is good for the national economy as it helps nurture businesses; however lessons can be learnt from the Indian state of Andhra Pradesh” Mr. Thompson noted.

In India, the head of a network of private micro-finance companies predicted that India's roaring private micro-finance industry will hit the buffers. He was worried by the reckless lending and feckless borrowing by micro-credit companies and villagers respectively. This has now led to borrowers defaulting on payments and taking their lives, and banks cutting off lending to the cash-strapped micro-loan companies.

At the root of it, many say, is the increasing greed of the private micro finance industry in India. Some of these companies are atrociously profitable. They lend more and more money to the same people, who then renege on repayments. Also, the uses of small loans have changed over the years, with mixed results. In the beginning, the loans were given out to help small traders sell vegetables or buy livestock, or for basic farming needs.

In recent years those farming commercial crops (cotton, groundnut, vegetables) or larger livestock (high-yielding buffaloes and cows) received micro-credit. Industry experts say this is all very well, but requires the borrower to be more astute about handling the "assets" bought with the loans. Also, small farmers often lack the education needed to handle "income shocks" arising from one bad crop or a glut in the market, leading to a lowering of prices.

But what has made the situation worse, say analysts, is that micro-loans have been given away freely to villagers to build homes, repay old debts, buy consumer durables like TV-sets and pay for family marriages. The bulk of the current micro finance lending is towards consumption. Now a state government has pushed through a tough new law that seeks to regulate the industry. These lessons affect an organisations level of risk and sometimes have more direct social consequences.

Mr. Thompson disclosed that, as a non-bank finance institution, Dalex Finance believes that, as a way forward for the industry, some form of annual inspection akin to the supervisory regime of the Bank of Ghana should be looked into. He observed: “If the industry contracts due to defaults, borrowers will be driven to money lenders who charge higher interest rates and have more unorthodox loan monitoring and collection mechanisms.”

There is also need for intensified public education on the industry; addressing questions on whether the Ghana Police is adequately resourced to vet applications of Lenders; and whether the industry provides opportunities for money laundering. Over the long-term the establishment of institutions similar to the Citizen Advice Bureaus in the UK, which amongst other things provide independent legal advice to borrowers, would be helpful.

Mr. Thompson noted that the future looked promising for Dalex Finance, which is a wholly Ghanaian owned company. Established in 2005 and headquartered at the Ringway Estates in Accra, the company has over 50 full-time employees, 270 Sales Executives and branches in Asylum Down, Accra, Kumasi and Takoradi. An office in Tamale is expected to be opened in July.

Dalex Finance provides business loans and loans to government workers, as well as operating leases, mainly for vehicles to companies in the telecoms, mining and oil and gas sectors.

Source: B&FT

SMEs need local government intervention - Mr. Turkson

The Chairman of the Association of Small Scale Industries (ASSI) in the Western Region, Mr. Douglas Turkson has urged metropolitan, municipal and district assemblies to empower their members through education, sensitization and orientation programs to make them more responsible in their planning and development activities.

He said Small Micro Enterprises need coaching to make them attractive to enable them access loans, as well as for police makers to take them serious and put in place measures to cater for their needs.

Mr. Turkson was addressing a workshop on Small and Micro Enterprises in Takoradi in the Western Region on Tuesday.

It was to address the challenges that SMEs of the Western Region face and also create a favorable environment for sustainable development of SMEs.

He acknowledged that the Western Region is now at the center of major development opportunities that require well thought-out sustainably initiatives to enable entrepreneurs maximize the benefits that would accrue from the emerging oil and gas industries.

He noted that SMEs can function as suppliers to large companies and thus serve as a major source of revenue to the local government authorities.

Mr. Turkson attributed poor financing of SMEs operation to lack of proper record keeping.


Source: myjoyonline.com

DANIDA and ARB Apex Bank sign $15 million agreement

The Danish International Development Agency (DANIDA) and ARB Apex Bank Limited, on Friday signed a $15 million agreement for Ghana’s private sector development.

Mr Jan Poulsen, Head of Mission at the Danish Embassy, who signed for DANIDA, said DANIDA was interested in helping to create sustainable jobs for people in the private sector to improve their living conditions.

He said the agreement signified a continued partnership between Denmark and Ghana and everything would be done to further build stronger relations between the countries.

Mr Poulsen said the $15 million package, an equivalent of about GH¢22 million, was to help the Bank to operate from 2011 to 2014 to develop the private sector and expressed the hope that the assistance would achieve its intended purpose.

Mr Eric Osei-Bonsu, Managing Director of ARB Apex Bank, who initialed for the Bank, said DANIDA’s assistance to rural banks begun in the 1990’s when the banks were supported with funds to undertake training needs and assessments.

He said human resource development of rural banks as well as capacity building of the staff of ARB Apex Bank was critical to any developmental initiatives, therefore, the assistance to improve the private sector would go a long way to enhance rural banking.

Mr Osei-Bonsu said if the Rural Community Banks (RCB) were merged, it would help serve the purpose of creating a very solid financial institution capable of meeting the various business improvement requests by RCB clients in their catchment areas.

He expressed the hope that the ideas and intentions envisaged in the Bank’s programmes would serve as a positive driver in the operational sustainability and progress of the rural banking sector.

Mr Osei-Bonsu thanked the Government and people of Denmark for their continuous support to Ghana and gave the assurance that the bank would build stronger bridges to ensure that the relations were strengthened.


Source: GNA

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Book Review

Title: Microfinance and Poverty Reduction: The Experience of Ghana

Author: Dr Joseph Kimos Adjei

No. of pages: 211

Publisher: Bold Communications Limited

Information on microfinance may abound in many books but when it comes to giving comprehensive insight to and making thorough analysis of the microfinance sector in Ghana, there may be no other book than the one titled ‘Microfinance and Poverty Reduction: The Experience of Ghana’, authored by Joseph Kimos Adjei, an academic and a practitioner in the field of microfinance.

The book is simply a masterpiece produced from long years of academic inquisition into and practical experience of the microfinance sector in Ghana. With long years of experience as credit manager in three prominent financial institutions in the country and a doctoral thesis on the subject, the author succeeds in breaking down the theoretical and practical intricacies of microfinance in general and the Ghana case in particular to the understanding of even those who may have low appreciation of microfinance. Coming in a beautifully-designed cover, the book is cast in eight main chapters. With a rich research background, the author spices the book with relevant graphs, tables, figures, academic references and scientific analyses that make the book very interesting reading. As the Executive Secretary of the Ghana Microfinance Institutions Network (GHAMFIN), Dr David O. Andah, who wrote the foreword to the book puts it, Microfinance and Poverty Reduction: The Experience of Ghana is “a must-read book for anyone interested in microfinance”. Indeed, the book is a masterpiece that players in the microfinance sector, researchers, lecturers and students of banking and finance, development studies and public policy will find more costly to forgo than to acquire at any price.

Chapter 1

The first chapter provides clues as to how microfinance could be used as an effective tool for poverty reduction. Microfinance programmes throughout the world have been adopted by various institutions in the developing world as one of the key strategies towards the reduction of poverty. In this regard, governments and developing partners have contributed in diverse ways resources to support the microfinance sector to expand their operations and increase the depth of outreach. Over the past three decades, various governments have adopted varied strategies including short and long term measures to address the problem of the high prevalence of poverty in their countries. These strategies include the technical assistance and funding for micro-credit activities and the creation of of an enabling environment for key players to provide financial services to the poor to improve their livelihood. The author gives a vivid overview of poverty reduction strategies in Ghana from 1980 to 2008, and the role of microfinance in reducing poverty in the country. The author observes that for most micro and small entrepreneurs in Ghana, the lack of access to financial services “is a critical constraint to the expansion of viable micro-enterprises”. Microfinance institutions have been allowed to operate and play a role in poverty reduction through the provision of small loans, savings and insurance products, money transfer and other financial and non-financial services to enable the poor generate income, build assets, and improve on their housing structures and related facilities.

Chapter 2

In chapter two, the author evaluates the development and success factors of microfinance in general, and makes a very intriguing comparison between micro-credit and microfinance. This chapter covers the development of the microfinance industry from the early 1980s when the focus was mainly on credit and other important financial services required by the poor were not provided. It also examined the era of state intervention in providing financial services to farmers and other disadvantaged individuals with poor repayment records, as well as contemporary times when most commercial banks and other non-bank financial institutions have deemed it necessary to enter this growing and profitable but competitive market. The innovative mechanisms and the unique methodologies adopted by microfinance institutions have also been explored. Challenges confronting the formal commercial banks who have ventured into the microfinance market were covered. Finally, ways by which these institutions, that had hitherto ignored this important sector of their economies, could chart a course into the sector have also been identified.

Chapter 3

In chapter three, Dr Adjei exhibits his rich understanding of theory and practice in microfinance by providing readers with evidence-based effects of microfinance programmes on poverty reduction and asset building. The chapter examines the empirical literature on microfinance and its effects on poverty reduction in general. The review placed a large emphasis on studies in South East Asia especially Bangledesh, where formal institutional microfinance programmes started and where we have a large body of literature on the effects of microfinance on poverty reduction. There are also some studies from sub-Sahara African countries including Ghana. The review of existing works by various authors and researchers confirms the conflicting and mixed results of the effectiveness of microfinance as a poverty reduction strategy. Notwithstanding, microfinance has emerged globally as an effective strategy for poverty reduction with the potential for far-reaching impact in transforming the lives of poor people. Overall, the review indicates that there is a common acceptance of the important role microfinance institutions are playing in poverty reduction efforts in developing countries. It has, however, been observed that most of these programmes are not reaching the very poor. It is further noted that such people could benefit from microfinance progammes only if such programmes are well-designed and targeted specifically at the poorest with some form of social welfare component attached.

Chapter 4

Chapter four of the book deals with contextual issues affecting microfinance in Ghana. The author examines some factors of poverty, such as population, the economy and inequality. He also discusses the geographical disparities in poverty levels, gender dimensions of poverty and policies to support microfinance programmes.

Making references to World Bank and Ghana Statistical Service data, Dr Adjei observes that although Ghana has achieved impressive economic growth rates since 1991, “poverty incidence and depth in the country remain high”. He enumerates many programmes introduced at various times with the view to reducing poverty.

These interventions include the Rural Finance Project, Rural Financial Services Project, Microfinance and Small Loans Centre and Ghana Microfinance Policy. Even though various programmes and policies have been adopted to reduce the incidence of poverty, not much has been achieved. As part of the strategy to solve this problem, government have placed greater emphasis on microfinance under the GPRS I and II and have also put in place an enabling environment for the microfinance sector through a microfinance policy document.

Chapter 5

Microfinance in Ghana has come a long way, and for people who may have little or no knowledge about the history of the sector, the author provides in chapter five of the book an in depth information on the evolution of microfinance in the country. In this chapter an overview has been provided of the important roles being played by various microfinance institutions in Ghana. As part of the strategy to reduce the level and incidence of poverty in the country and, therefore, attain some of the objectives of the Millennium Development Goals, the government has placed greater emphasis on microfinance by putting in place an enabling environment for the microfinance sector. We examined the evolution of the microfinance sector in the country to its current status. It must be noted that microfinance institutions in Ghana are arranged in three tiers, namely the formal, semi-formal and informal players. These institutions play important roles in the socio-economic development of the country, especially in the area of income generation, employment and poverty reduction. Through the provision of credit, savings and insurance products as well as non-financial services, most beneficiaries especially women, are able to expand their businesses and generate income to support their households.

Chapter 6

Having given such vivid account of the evolution of microfinance in Ghana, the author makes the book a class act by bringing readers up-close to the operations of microfinance institutions. Presenting a case study of Sinapi Aba Trust (SAT) in chapter six, he measures the depth of SAT’s outreach programmes through a survey that gives a better appreciation of the positive contributions of microfinance institutions. The results of the study indicate that, in general, SAT microfinance programme targets a disproportionately smaller number of the very poor in its operational areas, with approximately 46 per cent of its clients classified as less poor. These results are informed by the mission and objectives of the organization, the products and services it offers, as well as its policy of branch placement. The poverty assessment tool used for the analysis relies on varied poverty indicators reflecting the multi-dimensional nature of poverty and also offers an objective method for summarizing the overall poverty information of each household and unambiguously ranking these household by their relative poverty levels. Even though the method adopted for the analysis does not provide information on the absolute level of poverty of the two groups of respondents, it must be noted that, in most cases, it is the relative rather than the absolute poverty that is of concern to policy-makers and researchers.

Chapter 7

Focusing on microfinance, asset building and poverty reduction, the author makes another case study of SAT in chapter seven, examining the determinants of borrowing from SAT, while analysing the effects of its programmes on clients in terms of financial, human and physical capital/assets. The chapter examines how participation in a microfinance institution enabled established (old) clients to build up assets in the form of financial, human and physical capital in comparison to the new clients of the programme. The study found out that the size of loans is the key determinant of positive programme effects on participants. It was also observed that the level of education is positively related to the acquisition of household durables and that, most often, clients who are well educated normally serve as executive members of the various trust banks, and may be rewarded with larger loans for the assumed responsibilities. Another major finding of the study is the little or non-significant effect of the length of time with the programme on the outcomes variables. Generally, the findings of this study are consistent with other studies carried out by various researchers in Africa and South East Asia especially Bangladesh. It must be emphasized that even though these findings were obtained within the Ghanaian context, they could be applicable to microfinance institutions operating in other developing countries throughout the world.

Chapter 8

In tune with the adage that the past guides the future, the author peeps into the future in chapter eight, the last chapter of the book, as the author discusses some challenges facing the microfinance sector in the country and the way forward. The notes that the key challenges confronting the microfinance sector in developing countries, including Ghana, are capacity building; inadequate and expensive infrastructure base; poor credit delivery and management; inability to properly target the vulnerable and marginalized, research, monitoring and evaluation. On the way forward, the author underlines the need for microfinance institutions to expand access to commercial sources of funding in order to enlarge their operational tentacles. Furthermore, there is the need for microfinance institutions to develop the requisite skills and build good corporate governance, as well as dynamic and mission-oriented management to ensure efficiency.

Where to Obtain a Copy

Copies of the book can be obtained from the various public universities (i.e. University of Ghana (Business School, ISSER and the Bookshop) University of Cape Coast (Department of Economics); Kwame Nkrumah University of Science & Technology (KNUST Business School); University of Development Studies (both Tamale and Wa campus), UCC, KNUST, UDS) and selected bookshops across the country, as well as the offices of the National Banking College, GHAMFIN, Chartered Institute of Bankers, http://www.amazon.com and branches of HFC Bank where HFC Boafo Microfinance Services Ltd operates. One can also obtain copies from the publisher or the author.

Price: GH¢ 30 (Thirty Ghana cedis only).

Monday, April 11, 2011

"Credit Union Are Not Meant For Loans"

The credit union concept is to encourage the habit of savings and not purposely for granting loans to members, Mr Samuel Annor, Manager of the Central Region Chapter of the Credit Union Association (CUA) has stated.

He said it was unfortunate that in Ghana credit unions were associated with acquisition of loans mainly and urged the leadership of the societies to educate their members and the public to correct the misconception.

The CUA Chapter Manager gave the advice at a three-day management training workshop for the Board of Directors and members of the Committees of the Edwumapa Co-operative Credit Union established by the Mfantseman Municipal Assembly at Saltpond.

The Sub-committee on Gainful Employment (SPGE) of the International Labour Organisation’s Decent Work Project sponsored the workshop.

Some of the topics treated were; the credit union structure, credit union and CUA relationship, roles and responsibilities of credit union board, functions of loans and supervisory committees, and credit union policy.

Mr Annor, who facilitated the workshop, said credit unions should be regarded as a business which needed proper and efficient management.

He said he expected to see the Edwumapa Co-operative Credit Union growing to become one of the best in the region.

Mrs Grace Nicholls, Chairperson of SPGE said their mandate was to support the informal sector of the economy to grow, hence their decision to sponsor the workshop to prepare the credit union to thrive and contribute to the growth of the informal sector of the economy.

Mr John Etuah, Municipal Budget Analyst advised the participants to take the workshop seriously and be well vexed with the rules and regulations of the credit union concept since they held the key to the success of the body.

He urged them to, as much as possible; enforce the laws without fear or favour.

Mr Tsetse Arthur, Chairman of the Board of Directors appealed to the SPGE to provide allowances to people who would be invited to workshops as “going home with empty hands” after spending three days was very demoralising and would not encourage participants to respond to future invitations.


Source: Peacefmonline

ECOWAS reviews regional investment laws

A technical meeting to harmonize the investment laws in ECOWAS member states has ended in Port Novo, Benin.

The six-day meeting enabled the participants to compare the framework Community Investment Code (CIC) with the investment laws of member states, and use the reports of the national consultants to determine areas of convergence and divergence.

During the meeting, Peter Oluonye of the Directorate of Private Sector who represented the Commissioner for Macroeconomic Policy, Professor Lambert Bamba, recalled that the Commission had engaged the national consultants to conduct a study and analysis of the investment laws of their respective countries.

Their reports, he said, would constitute the basis of the harmonization process and enjoined them to demonstrate the same diligence with the next phase of the process guided by the realization that the treatment of investment in a single economic space will position ECOWAS as a competitive destination for investment in the global market.

The Framework CIC provisions were later reviewed comprehensively against the provisions of member states' respective constitutions; commercial laws sector codes and national investment codes.

The experts agreed that the spirit of the Framework CIC converges with most provisions in the member states' investment laws, a situation that paves the way for the re-drafting of the framework CIC document into investment code for ECOWAS, based on the outcome of the meeting by the national consultants.

Source: BF&T

ECLOF launches new unit

ECLOF-Ghana has launched a business development services (BDS) unit by which it aims to provide non-financial services that are vital to the development of sustainable microenterprises.

It is a Christian development organisation born out of the Christian Council of Ghana and belonging to the ECLOF global family with its head office in Geneva.

The principal aim of the BDS unit is to raise financial literacy levels, as well as managerial skills, among ECLOF’s clients by teaching new knowledge, skills and attitudes expected to bring about changes in money and management behaviour.

The BDS unit has a target of taking a minimum of 5,000 clients through this imperative exercise.

Currently ECLOF-Ghana has over 7,500 clients, with a portfolio of over US$1.5m; and with its policy of bringing finance and non-financial services close to its clients, ECLOF aims at broadening its presence countrywide, which currently stands at twenty outlets in five regions of the country.

ECLOF’s core business remains the provision of financial services to the unbanked in the country by providing micro, small and medium size enterprises (MSMEs) access to credit, building lump-sums, financial literacy, and insurance.

The BDS will additionally serve as a tool to promote financial inclusion, enabling people to take greater advantage of the financial services available to them. The business education is expected to translate into such actions and offer insights to help in transforming the lives of clients in particular and the entirety of the informal sector.

The BDS is organised by well-trained officials with requisite participatory learning skills. Training is held in ECLOF units and during meeting schedules on the field. Each client has an attendance book that is marked.

Upon full completion of a 10-module course, clients are awarded with certificates. Very good participants are then used as resource persons, and they enjoy reductions in interest rates on ECLOF’s loan products.

ECLOF is aiming to undertake financial literacy lessons for both existing clients and prospective ones, and organise business clinics for its SME clients in the future.

All ECLOF’s clients are expected to go through its financial literacy lessons and free medical screening to attract relatively lower interest rates on its loan products.

ECLOF Ghana began its operations in 1978.

It is a private Christian Micro Finance Institution and a non-political, non-governmental organisation having a mission of mobilising resources and offering sustainable customer-centered financial services for the total development of its clients and the benefit of all stakeholders.

Source: Business and Financial Times